Home » Gig » Reviews » Currently Reading:

Kasabian, Eden Sessions

Kasabian - image by Gareth Lloyd

Kasabian - image by Gareth Lloyd

July 4, 2009

For thousands of years, the heated debate between creationists and those of us with bloody common sense has raged; is Darwin’s Theory of Evolution the reason we’re all here living and breathing, or was woman created from Adam’s rib and let loose in a garden of riches only to cause humankind’s eternal condemnation? (If you’re having trouble deciding, you might not want to read much more). However, tonight at Cornwall’s majestic Eden Project, a surreal and disturbing rewriting of the time/space/belief continuum is occurring as Neanderthals invade the verdant former clay pit to see Kasabian become the least fitting band to grace a stage since John Mayer at MJ’s funeral. Crowd highlights include a chap wearing a t-shirt wondering “Is it necrophilia if it’s still twitching?”, blokes comparing how many midgets they know (two apiece, apparently) over their respective six pint trays of cider, and hordes of delightful types dropping empty beer cups and fag ends in the sweet pea patches. If we’re searching hard for silver linings, at least they’re ignoring The Hours, whose dulling tones make it seem plausible that Kasabian might actually provide some sort of musical relief.

Please, someone pinch me. As Kasabian strut on stage seemingly in order of self-perceived importance, the only relief they could offer might be to an stratospherically obese person thinking about getting back into exercise, as they demand that we put our hands in the air for the first of more than 20 times in a 15 song set. The command constantly spills from Tom Meighan’s lips as if he has attention-seeking Tourettes, joining his messianic spread arms in an hubristic display that’s embarrassing to watch. They boom on with ‘Underdog’, the opener of West Ryder Pauper Lunatic Asylum, which psyches up the crowd with pithy sentiments like “lost in a moment” and easy to grasp expansive concepts such as “sky” and “future”. Profound. The empty sentiment omnipresent in their songs forms a vicious circle live – they sing about “doing it for the people”, who in turn respond with unabated glee (throwing nine pint cups per minute due to the wanton abandon that Kasabian provoke), spurring Meighan’s foolhardy ego on. It makes pooping back and forth forever look appealing…

By second number, ‘Shoot The Runner’, it becomes pretty clear that this is The Tom Meighan Show – the lesser band members know their place, occasionally twitching like press puppets yet utterly unresponsive to the crowd, without a hint of interaction or intuition between them. Whenever it’s not Meighan’s turn to take the limelight – during an instrumental part or song led by Serge’s nasal tones – he disappears offstage. You can only hope it’s a sign of inner band strife that’ll cause them to split within a few years.

“This place is fucking like Tracy Island,” contributes Meighan by way of the obligatory wonderment bands must show at playing in front of the two space age biomes. “Like Thunderbirds.” Jolly glad you cleared that up for us, cheers. He misses his cue to come in on ‘Processed Beats’ yet struts on smug and self-satisfied, asking for hands in the air again, then tells us we’re “fucking empire!” (no prizes for guessing what comes next). A trumpeter appears for the mildly Baltic influenced ‘Where Did All The Love Go’, which has all the cultural nous of a football fan who’s been to Latvia once for a match, ‘Thick As Thieves’ is a note for note rip off of The Beatles’ ‘I’m Only Sleeping’, but the crowd’s swaying, men are topless and hugging and there’s a thousand mobile phones in the air. What’s wrong with people?! ‘Fire’ has the tuneless football terrace roar of 90% of their songs, a technique defended by a bloke next to us – “they don’t need words, their songs are so fucking brilliant that they can really tug your heartstrings without them y’know?” Mm. By ‘Club Foot’, Meighan’s caught on to exactly the same thing, so doesn’t even bother articulating the lyrics. To avoid the crush for the car parks, we escape the encore, but hear the notes of a cod ‘You Got The Love’ cover float up past the visitor centre (first line: “sometimes I feel like putting my hands up in the air”), the crowd roaring along euphorically. Debate over monkeys and clay figures aside, this is a cultural devolution that must be fought, defeated and crushed.

Written by Laura Snapes

The first gig she ever attended was by The Corrs, and, at the time of writing, the last was by a local covers band murdering Winehouse's version of 'Valerie' (however, highlights in between include Joanna Newsom at the Royal Albert Hall, Jens Lekman at ATP, and Monotonix at Miss Peapods). She's terrible at remembering song names, thus has a lot of respect for the woman who once came into the record shop where she worked, and hummed the entire of The Cardigans' 'My Favourite Game' in an attempt to find out what it was called. After 20 years on the planet, the capacity to like things rationally continues to desert her as she plunges into musical and cinematic obsessions with abandon (right now: Rachel's, and Wim Wenders). Her first published article was an interview with the illustrious Thirteen Senses (causing her 14 year old knees to quiver with excitement), which led to a bout of cocksureness whereby she pretended to be the music editor of the local paper in an attempt to interview Keane (Cornwall doesn't get a great deal of gigs passing through). The security guard went to check her credentials, and came back with the real editor. Laura loves the squeakiness of grilled halloumi between her teeth, Adrien Brody's nose, Jens Lekman's Swedish baritone, Camille's francophone folly, ATP and a pint on Gyllyngvase Beach.

  • Sean C
    I am of the belief that all Kasabian fans should be sterilised.
  • truthspeaker
    seconded
  • oscarlizard
    oh you lovely nazi you
  • MitchellStirling
    I'm off to write a review of a BNP rally, mustn't criticise the ideology and politics behind what is being said though, will just adapt my review to those in the crowd that enjoy it.
  • Super Massive Will
    Laura, please learn how to write, and just maybe, review.

    It is not about personal opinions when reviewing a live performance. Look at the band and the fans, you said yourself they were "roaring along euphorically". If a band are not to your taste you have to adapt the review to suit those that do enjoy it. If the performance is poor, say it. Don't constantly criticise the music behind it. Clearly you had a premeditated opinion and were ready with the knife.

    It's also worth doing a little background research. Meighan is famous for having very bad ADD, therefore comments along the lines of "as if he has attention-seeking Tourettes" probably aren't the most appropriate.

    This article made me angry, you string together your opinions with a series of bad smilies and metaphors. Any journalist will tell you these are required in serious moderation.
  • If by "bad smilies" you mean "bad similes", I am against moderation. And I'm a journalist! Check that out.

    PS What is a bad smiley? Is it you?
  • Jiten Karia
    Fans "roaring along euphorically" means absolute rubbish in terms of reviewing a gig.

    And besides, it appears Laura's done a fine job of being a journalist. What's the point of being a journalist if you can't get people to read what you've written?

    Really, there should be a thank you here for you, just for not understanding that the reviewer has a right to opinion, and thereby making this review more read.

    Bravo Laura.
  • Emma
    Laura Snapes, you diabolical excuse for a journalist.
    Agreed with all the points Will made, you shouldn't be allowed to "review" music or live performances.
    Truly abysmal, you can tell you've got a lot of growing up to do...
    Have fun trying to make a career doing this!
  • hollyseddon
    Wow! That's funny on so many levels... not the 'because it's true' level though.
  • Right now, somewhere in heaven, Steven Wells is slapping a Kasabian fan round the chops with an overextended metaphor
  • Terrible band this lot. How they sell records, I'll never know, the horrific bunch of clowns.
  • See, what you people have done is disagree with the opinion of a reviewer based on the obvious fact that you are fan boys (and girls) of the reviewed band.
    What I can see up there ^^ is a quite brilliantly written review of a band that just didn't cut the mustard for the reviewer. The reasons for the uncut mustard are stated numerously (and eloquently).
    Why do people get so needlessly defensive when someone criticises a band they like? In your review burning world, this review would read 'I didn't really like this performance but I could see that people did so it must have been good'

    I'll happily take this 'diabolical excuse' over your world.
  • Dear all,

    Many thanks for the entertainment received this evening. I was never before aware of what PeterHarris kindly summarised as the "I didn't really like this performance but I could see that people did so it must have been good" branch of critical theory, so cheers for that. I'll shelve it in between feminism and Marxism.

    Super Massive Will, I believe that live reviews are all about personal opinions, or at least critical observations formed in the reviewer's mind outside of the extraordinarily prosiac "they played this song, and then they drummed fast, and then they sang loud" approach that you seem to be advocating. And as for Meighan being "famous for having very bad ADD", it took a few minutes to find the scant articles on Google detailing that Noel Gallagher revealed that the way to calm Meighan down is by taking him to Toys R Us. Hardly a fame-worthy condition eh? Anyway, here's my opinion of the gig in a series of bad smilies for you: O.o %-( :-@ |-O

    Dear Emma, I'm terribly sorry that you feel I'm a diabolical journalist just because I slagged off your favourite band. Although hopefully somewhere in that sentence lies an implication about any growing up that needs doing...

    I'm off to review Razorlight at the same venue tomorrow, so be sure to pop back at the weekend to get your knickers in a twist again.
  • I'm confused by your response to my comment - you do realise that I was defending your review yes?
  • Yeah yeah, I was being genuinely grateful! Good succinctness, I couldn't think of a way to put it better myself.
  • i went to this gig and i can say i thought it was really good!
    yes the people throwing beers were fucking annoying but kasabian put on a really good show, decent lightshow, good sound levels and they got the songs to make the crowd move! real good atmosphere!
    good gig!
  • ddpp
    Well, i went and loved it. I am 42, and took my 13 yr old son. Good old fashioned rock in a beautiful setting. Do reviewers sometimes forget what they are tasked to do?
  • Kirstie McCrum
    "Do reviewers sometimes forget what they are tasked to do?"

    Um, possibly, but not in this case... It is a review, n'est-ce pas?

    Well done Laura.
  • Keef
    tom meighan is a proper big-headed arrogant rocker who thinks grilled halloumi is an altered state usually experienced after licking a bullfrog on a beach in venezeula. he once pretended to be mick jagger to gain the part of lead vocalist in the midlands ruffneck beat combo now trading under the name of kasabian. he can urinate into a beer glass while lying on his back playing America on the ukelele and is able to run a sub-four-minute mile while eating a chicken doner. tom is shortly to venture on a sell-out stadium tour but still finds time to point out that it is mere conjecture, if not a misunderstanding of the species, to suggest that the homo sapien is an evolution of the neanderthal. Both belong to the homo genus grouping but there is no evidencial evolutionary link other than the fact that both are able to RAISE THEIR HANDS IN THE AIR!!! C'MOOOOONNNN!!!!!!!!
  • lukerodgers
    Well you've sparked a nice debate, so you must be doing something right. Although the pomposity that has littered the comments seems somewhat unneccessary.

    From the sounds of it, I'm guessing that you didn't like Kasabian before the gig, which begs the question why were you there?

    My own opinion is that if your not a fan of the team then get out of the stadium.
  • I'll be sure to tell that to the away fans next time I go to watch my beloved Championship-dwelling Newcastle...
  • lukerodgers
    Well you could do that but being as they are "fans of the team" albeit the away team I think they'll stay and watch the match!
  • Ahh
    Ahh, a review from a woman who tried to blag her way backstage to interview the epitome of musical averageness.

    I don't think I'll be back. And that comes from someone who neither loves Kasabian, nor pompous tripe.

    I hope your 'career' as a Journalist continues to burgeon. I'd imagine the bands 'inner strife' might outlast you though.

    All the best.

    A purveyor of good taste.
  • Gill
    I'm sorry to hear the reviewer didn't enjoy the gig, having seen Kasabian live on tv at Glastonbury and, my personal favourite, at the electric proms I had a pretty good idea what they were like before I went and they didn't let me down.

    It may well come down to personal preference, but I've always liked their music. They have a good ear for a tune and display moments of genius and real musicianship in their songs. My parents are both rock 'n roll fans from the 70's, something I've inherited, and that retro sound fused with modern beats makes for a cracking sound. Also the personalities in the band work well, the ego/swagger of Tom and his ability to belt out a tune, and then the more enigmatic Sergio with his softer voice, shown brilliantly on tracks like me plus one and Thick as thieves are a brilliant contrast ensuring the band should have some longevity.
    So as for the gig, the band couldn't have been better. The atmosphere around us was amazing, when 'Fire' started the crowd went a littly crazy and I found myself bouncing around grinning madly at complete strangers. The test of a band is always can they sound the same live as they do on the CD and the answer was a resounding YES! Better in parts. The Doberman was brilliant and Shoot the Runner will always be a favourite.
    Negatives - yes their were some, I am capable of being impartial. Firstly the set could have been longer, in that hour and half we got all the tunes we loved, but their were a few slower tracks on the new album that could have changed the pace throughout. Also while Eden looked amazing at night and I know the staff work hard, I thought the organisation for the gig was quite poor. Their were only two bars and my mate was stuck in the queue for almost an hour, missing the rather dull 'The Hours' support act. Also the recent trend for throwing beer/plastic glasses throughout the gig continues to be hazardous, really unpleasant if you get soaked and just a waste of beer.
    The other nitpick I have is with the exits, when the gig finished everyone piled towards the same exit with it taking an awfully long time to get to the top where we were informed by police that if you wanted Taxis then they were back down the path and out another exit. We passed several Eden staff along the way and everyone failed to mention were the taxi rank was. Poor communication.

    Still those problems in the end did nothing to spoil the night and my dream of seeing Kasabian live came true in the most magical venue I could possibly imagine. If you are a fan of the band you wouldn't have been dissapointed, and if you're not, why would you buy a ticket anyway?

    Gill, Liverpool
  • Sean C
    Why do all these people think that Laura bought a ticket? For people who claim to know what reviewing music is like, they don't really seem to understand the concept of comps.
  • ellen
    do me a favour go back to uni and forget about writing reviews.
    your bored the shite out of me after the first 2 lines.
  • oscarlizard
    Oh dear...
    dear Laura Snapes at some point beyond beyond your uninformed 20 years on this planet you will realise you are actually no good good at this reviewing game, good luck with finding your true vocation.
    ps This was a great gig and 13 Senses were total Poo.. er journalist my arse!
  • oscarlizard
    oh yes maybe it should also be said that our pompous reviewers favourite artist is bleedin ..Alex Parks
    oh lordy
  • It strikes me that if this was real life, it would constitute one side (they'd be mute) throwing bottles of cat piss at each other and the responding sensible retort promulgating through a beautiful loudspeaker, referencing key figures from our past.
  • This is exactly what music should be doing - stimulating debate and comment. And it's purely because we all LOVE music to death that we get out our metaphorical (I hope) bottles of piss.

    I'm glad we haven't reached a place where nobody has anything to say about music anymore. Keep it up.
  • peterbloxham
    A well written piece, Laura. I've appreciated your stuff before, but there was a lot to like about this. You're definitely one of the more talented among us at the moment.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Comment on this Article:







Buy tickets

You will probably love these too...

Hot Chip – One Life Stand

February 7, 2010

Still one of the most unique bands of the past decade.

The Fiery Furnaces – Take Me Around Again

February 7, 2010

Anyone for seconds? The Friedbergers play it again. And again.

Mike Doughty – London Relentless Garage

February 5, 2010

February 2nd 2010
“I want to be on you”.  Ron Burgundy’s “immortal words” are those chosen by Mike Doughty to sell himself to the British public.
Doughty, formerly of alt-rock band Soul Coughing, is pretty popular in the States, but relatively unknown here.  My question referred to selling himself to us in the style of a dating [...]

Chemikal Underground’s Celtic Connections – Glasgow ABC

February 2, 2010

If you’re looking to name a contemporary independent Scottish label, there’s a chance Chemikal Underground will be the first. Originally set up by The Delgados to release their debut single, they quickly established themselves as the most important label in Scotland since Postcard releasing records by the likes of Arab Strap, Mogwai, Aereogramme, Bis, Mother [...]

The Ex + Brass Unbound + Zun Zun Egui – Bristol Fleece

February 2, 2010

January 29th 2010
There’s a keenly felt sense of anticipation in the Fleece this evening. As well as being the first of The Ex’s performances with the formidable Brass Unbound roster – Mats Gustafsson, Ken Vandermark, Roy Paci and Walter Wierbos – the bill also features local firebrands Zun Zun Egui, a band that sorely deserve [...]

Follow us on Twitter…

Become a fan on Facebook…

Join the conversation...

  • nestaF: I agreeIt was a GREAT night...
  • Csagarhouse: Hi There. My band would love to get involved, We are...
  • alexellis: Hi, Sounds interesting!! Here's the Myspace!! ...
  • Kilf: You dis Dan and Scroob and call yourself a muso?...
  • basslady: HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO ME!...
  • liamjohn: Hello,check out ...
  • Paul Faller: Hmm. I think you're being very harsh on Favourite Worst ...
  • PeterHarris: My favourite artist to use the word spelunking is Joanna New...
  • josegiles01: Medical billing is the fast growing field. Find your local s...
  • josegiles01: Medical billing is the fast growing field. Find your local s...

Win tickets to see Casiokids in London

Casiokids.jpg

Norway's electro pop quintet CASIOKIDS play Camden’s Barfly on February 25, and we're giving away a pair of tickets.

After the release of a few stellar singles in 2009, 2010 is looking exciting for this lot. Their bouncy percussive basement music, eerie melody and distorted bass are the product of inspiration from such diverse sources as Paul Simon's 'Graceland', Ivor Cutler, King Tubby, Bob Hund, Cornelius And Fela Kuti.

To win tickets, just answer the following question:

Which label are CASIOKIDS signed to?

We are listening

Blog Widget by LinkWithin